How to Have a Younger Church
It was thought-provoking to read Bishop Frank Caggiano’s wise words at Fordham on March 12, when he said that “young people are leaving the Catholic Church not because they are angry—but because they are indifferent.” Their lack of interest, he continued, was because “there are questions unresolved, and young people simply don’t have the mental energy or desire to figure it out.” There is much to agree with here, especially the implied distinction between the attitudes of older church-going Catholics to our currently dysfunctional church and those of the younger generation who, in most cases, are not regularly practicing. In my own experience of almost 40 years teaching undergraduates, I can concur with Bishop Caggiano that anger is not a common late-adolescent response to church matters. Perhaps “indifference” is a bit soft. I would probably want to say that they aren’t angry, because they don’t care. The church doesn’t matter to so many of them, so why would they be angry? The bishop is also correct that meeting questioners where they are in a respectful and nonjudgmental posture of listening is of paramount importance. Good pastors and educators understand that, while the less successful ones trot out pat answers to questions that may not actually have been asked. To borrow from the wisdom of St. Ignatius of Loyola, he is so insistent in his advice to spiritual directors that they get out of the way and allow the spirit to work on the minds and hearts of the searcher. Which means, of course, that a mentor’s patience must approximate the patience of God which, as we know, is endless. Listening, as the bishops says, can be more important than talking.
However, if young people are drifting away from the church because they don’t care rather than because they are angry, let me suggest that they don’t care because what they encounter in the church is too often something that does not speak to their hearts or inflame their souls. Young people, in my experience, are patient with imperfection but intolerant of hypocrisy. They can sure spot a phony a hundred miles away. If you don’t believe me, browse sometime on the dishonest educator’s nemesis, www.ratemyprofessors.com. Whether for good or ill, there is no parallel reviewing system for pastors and bishops. Perhaps we ought to have one? And if we did, we would see a lot of understanding of the average guy doing his best, real appreciation for the one whose openness and honesty shines through and profound distaste for pretentiousness and false pride.
What really causes young people not to care rather than be angry is that they have written the church off, too often perhaps before they have given it a real chance. I think Bishop Caggiano is onto something when he writes about the beauty of the liturgy, but you have to be in the building to appreciate it. On the whole, they are not there for several reasons. First, the liturgy is as often as not pretty routine, and while that might be fine for those of us who have the ritual deep in our psyches, it doesn’t work to entice someone in. Second, the ethical values of the young, as opposed to their occasionally amoral practices (and how different are they here than the rest of us?) are not respected within the confines of the institutional church. A particular pastor may be receptive to an individual who comes to him. But the church itself is simply inconceivably unrealistic to the majority of young Catholics on same-sex relationships, on cohabitation before marriage and on the use of birth control. Most adult Catholics shrug their shoulders at the anachronistic approach of the church on these issues and carry on worshipping, perhaps because they understand deep down that the Lord is not always in agreement with the teaching of the church. But the young don’t have that patience. It’s not so much that they are not in the church, as that the church is not in the world they live in.
All that Bishop Caggiano suggested as ways to attract the young is wise and compassionate. But I would add a few things. Most importantly, weed out hypocrisy, whether it is bishops who hide abusers or senior church leaders who manage to be simultaneously closeted gays and homophobic. Then, our ethical teaching needs to be expressed in the knowledge of human frailty and imperfection, and with the honest acceptance of difference. Do not tell people that birth control for the unmarried is always self-indulgence and not sometimes responsible. Do not assume that cohabitation is always the road to future marital ruin, since it often isn’t. And do not assume that same-sex relationships can never be as loving and fulfilling as straight ones. All this would just be more fake news, and the church does not need to go that way. Maybe, even, encourage gay clergy to be open about their sexual orientation. The sky will not fall in, and there could be no better way to signal to gay Catholics that the church welcomes them. There used to be, years ago and happily long-gone, a column in the Fairfield County Catholic entitled “The Narrow Gate.” Nothing could be less Catholic. As James Joyce so famously described our church, “Here Comes Everybody.” Every one of our parishes should put out that big banner you see often adorning the church buildings of the U.C.C.—“All Are Welcome.” When this is what the Catholic Church proclaims, and when it really means it, and when it has done it for a while, the young will be back. It’s not doctrine or ethics or liturgy that they find most distasteful. They know, and they want the church to know, that love has no boundaries.
Paul Lakeland is a teacher, scholar and director of the Center for Catholic Studies at Fairfield University.
Well said. I think God is crying for the church today and for the superior, haughty, lack of humility, of many, but not all, pastoral "leaders". Also don't underestimate the damage that is done to the elders at their last stage of living on this earth.
Posted by: Francisca Hutton | 04/16/2019 at 04:24 PM
Posted by: Wendy | 04/18/2019 at 10:28 AM
God’s desired for the church are simple - just read the two greatest commandments of Jesus.
Hypocrisy by the hierarchy is the leading cause for problems. Bishops and Cardinals living in magnificent houses, catering to the moneyed, rather than the needy.
After 62 years as a Catholic, not only raised and educated in Catholic schools; but also as a significant employee of a major Diocese - I couldn’t live with my compromises, and anger.
Now I am Episcopalian and in a Church with the same beautiful liturgy as RC, complete acceptance, and loving married clergy INCLUDING women!
Bishops are selected by the laity of the Diocese, as well as priest chosen by the parish. NOT political appointees.
Posted by: Bruce Corrigan | 04/21/2019 at 11:56 AM
I do not believe the problem involves youth leaving the church, but rather the youth never having been part of church.
We have lost a couple of generations of youth who have become parents. Generation after generation the ill-prepared Catholics have been unable and or unwilling to raise their children in a faith oriented environment.
There was a time when the common complaint centered around children being baptized, having received communion, and confirmation leaving the church until their children entered this process of initiation. Repeated generation after generation the issue now is folks no longer come to the church for marriage. Their children are not Presented for initiation .the pews are becoming more empty as older generations of practicing Catholics pass away.
During the years these events were occurring, higher Ups were caught up in high philosophical disputes, academic arguments involving canon law, and let us not forget the time, talent, and energy devoted to taking a perfectly fine expression of liturgy and turning it into a liturgy that gives no respect to common language or every day custom.
Having gotten their way and made all things perfect they've awakened to find empty church buildings!
Having too much pride for introspection ......the problem is the world that hates us and is therefore bad.......even though God created it and found it good.
For those parents who do send their children for instruction.......45 minutes of free babysitting is not cutting it folks.
Posted by: Jim | 04/25/2019 at 11:38 AM
Thank you, Paul L. I find your observation/s helpful &, for me, somewhat accurate.
"It what it is!" Comes to my mind.
The power of liturgy, mindfully well crafted, inclusive, engaging & addressing the community's current 'felt pain' as well as its great capacity for empathy & generosity can & often does energize "we the people" to embrace, give, assist, share & listen deeply to each other. & Then, to search out the persons "left out" in our culture & in our local towns & cities. I do see that locally in my parish &, more broadly, in the endurance of strong assistance programs, for homeless families, for hungry people, for questioning &, somewhat lonely people. Thanks, again.
(&, Fairfield U is a fav!!, for me.)
Posted by: Patricia Billings | 05/14/2019 at 12:32 PM
Thank you so much. It is so comforting to know that there are other Catholics out there who think like me. You give me hope.
Posted by: Debbie Wentworth | 05/17/2019 at 12:02 PM